2004 All-Conference

First Team
Ryan Esbaugh, Running Back
Kyle Kaminski, Center
Mike Koster, Receiver
Keith Nichol, Quarterback
John Rasch, Guard
Brock Graham, Outside Linebacker
Jeremy Holliman, Outside Linebacker
Mike McElroy, Defensive Back
Frank Mulder, Defensive Back
Scott Perdaris, Defensive Tackle
Ed Zigmont, Defensive End

Honorable Mention
Mike Wildey, Guard

2003 All-Conference

First Team
Mike Koster, Receiver
Ed Zigmont, Defensive Tackle
Jeff McPherson, Linebacker
Frank Mulder, Defensive Back

Honorable Mention
Ryan Esbaugh, Running Back
Ryand Dykhouse, Quarterback

2002 All-Conference

First Team
Mark Catlin, Quarterback
Andy McQueen, Center
Mike Koster, Receiver
Jordan Moore, Linebacker
JJ Wilder, Defensive Back

Honorable Mention
Matt Foster, Kicker
Ben Barle, Defensive Tackle

2001 All-Conference

First Team
Mark Catlin, Quarterback
Ben Fleet, Center
Ben Vaught, Offensive Tackle
Travis DeVoid, Linebacker
Brandon Biggs, Defensive End

Honorable Mention
Brad Eldridge, Receiver
Bill Harrison, Defensive Back

2000 All-Conference

First Team
Josh Brown, Quarterback
Ken Palcowski, Running Back
Chris Rittersdorf, Offensive Tackle
Mark Catlin, Reciever
Pete VanLaan, Defensive Back
Nate Borth, Defensive End
Neil Riembold, Linebacker
Brandon Biggs, Defensive Line

Honorable Mention
Matt Jackson, Offensive Guard

1999 All-Conference

First Team
Bill Stouffer, Defensive End
Luke Seitz, Offensive Guard
Tim Schutte, Offensive Tackle
Mike Williams, Free Safety
Brady Foster, Kicker

Honorable Mention
Caleb Grummet, Defensive Tackle
Tom Oesch, Nose Guard
Josh Brown, Quarterback

1998 All-Conference

First Team
TJ Thayer, Quarterback
Andy Graham, Receiver
Bill Stouffer, Offensive Center
Dustin Gless, Defensive Back

Honorable Mention
Brady Foster, Kicker
Steve VanLaan, Running Back
Jason Alber, Offensive Tackle

1997 All-Conference

First Team
TJ Thayer, Quarterback
Steve VanLaan, Running Back
Chris Weiland, Offensive Guard
Nate Shoen, Offensive Tackle
Kevin Teunis, Receiver
Brian Bellechases, Linebacker
Tim VanLaan, Defensive Back

Honorable Mention
Jeff Altoft, Defensive Tackle
Kevin Condon, Nose Tackle

1996 All-Conference

First Team
Jeff Catlin, Quarterback
Nate Lietzke, Offensive Tackle
Pat Johnson, Defensive End
Jeff Altoft, Defensive Tackle
Mike Curtis, Defensive Back